Season 1
| Cheftastant | Harold Dieterle (1st) | Tiffani Faison (2nd) |
| Elimination wins | 1/10 | 2/10 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 5/10 | 5/10 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 2/10 | 3/10 |
| Quickfire wins | 2/10 | 1/10 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 3- Dave Martin (3rd)
Most Quickfire Wins: 3- Lee Anne Wong (4th)_
Most Top 3s (including wins):5 Harold Dieterle, Tiffiani Fiason, and Stephen Asprinio (5th)
Most Bottom 3s: 4 Dave Martin and Andrea Beaman (7th)
Season 2
| Cheftastant | Ilan Hall (1st) | Marcel Vigneron (2nd) |
| Elimination wins | 2/12 | 1/12 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 3/12 | 4/12 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 2/12 | 3/12 |
| Quickfire wins | 1/11 | 3/11 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 2- Ilan Hall, Elia Aboumrad (4th), and Betty Fraser (7th)
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Cliff Crooks (5th)
Most Top 3s (including wins): 6 –Betty Fraser
Most Bottom 3s: 5- Cliff Crooks and Michael Midgley (6th)
Season 3
| Cheftastant | Hung Huynh (1st) | Dale Levitski (2nd) | Casey Thompson (3rd) |
| Elimination wins | 1/13 | 1/13 | 2/13 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 6/13 | 5/13 | 4/13 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 3/13 | 4/13 | 4/13 |
| Quickfire wins | 4/13 | 2/13 | 3/13 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 3- Tre Wilcox (8th)
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Hung Huynh
Most Top 3s (including wins): 6- Hung Huynh
Most Bottom 3s: 6- Brian Malarkey (4th)
Season 4
| Cheftastant | Stephanie Izard (1st) | Richard Blais (2nd) | Lisa Fernandes (2nd) |
| Elimination wins | 4/13 | 4/13 | 1/13 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 10/13 | 7/13 | 2/13 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 3/13 | 1/13 | 6/13 |
| Quickfire wins | 2/13 | 3/13 | 0/13 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 4- Stephanie Izard and Richard Blais
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Antonia Lofaso (4th)
Most Top 3s (including wins): 10- Stephanie Izard
Most Bottom 3s: 6- Lisa Fernandes and Evangelos “Spike” Mendelsohn (5th)
Season 5
| Cheftastant | Hosea Rosenberg (1st) | Stefan Richter (2nd) | Carla Hall (3rd) |
| Elimination wins | 2/13 | 5/13 | 3/13 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 4/13 | 7/13 | 6/13 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 4/13 | 3/13 | 3/13 |
| Quickfire wins | 1/13 | 4/13 | 1/13 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 5- Stefan Richter
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Stefan Richter
Most Top 3s (including wins): 7- Stefan Richter
Most Bottom 3s: 4- Hosea Rosenberg
Season 6
| Cheftastant | Michael Voltagiio (1st) | Bryan Voltaggio (2nd) | Kevin Gillespie (3rd) |
| Elimination wins | 3/13 | 4/13 | 5/13 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 9/13 | 8/13 | 8/13 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 1/13 | 0/13 | 1/13 |
| Quickfire wins | 2/13 | 0/13 | 4/13 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 5- Kevin Gillespie
Most Quickfire Wins :4- Kevin Gillespie and Jennifer Carroll (4th)
Most Top 3s (including wins): 9- Michael Voltaggio
Most Bottom 3s: 4=- Jennifer Carroll, Robin Leventhal (6th), and Laurine Wickett Hope (8th)
Season 7
| Cheftastant | Kevin Sbraga (1st) | Ed Cotton (2nd) | Angelo Sosa (3rd) |
| Elimination wins | 1/13 | 3/13 | 2/13 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 4/13 | 6/13 | 4/13 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 5/13 | 2/13 | 2/13 |
| Quickfire wins | 1/13 | 3/13 | 4/13 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 3- Ed Cotton
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Angelo Sosa
Most Top 3s (including wins): 7- Tiffany Derry (5th)
Most Bottom 3s: 5- Kevin Sbraga and Amanda Baumgarten (6th)
Season 8
| Cheftastant | Richard Blais (1st) | Mike Isabella (2nd) |
| Elimination wins | 4/15 | 2/15 |
| Top 3 Call outs | 8/15 | 4/15 |
| Bottom 3 Call outs | 1/15 | 3/15 |
| Quickfire wins | 4/14 | 4/14 |
Season Summary
Most Elimination Wins: 4- Richard Blais
Most Quickfire Wins: 4- Richard Blais, Mike Isabella, and Dale Talde (6th)
Most Top 3s (including wins): 8- Richard Blais
Most Bottom 3s: 8- Tiffany Derry (4th)
The first thing that popped out at me when looking at the season breakdown is that Richard wasn't nearly as robbed as the editors would like us to believe. Stephanie consistently preformed well in her season, winning just as many challenges as him and landing in the top 3 more often then he did. In fact with ten top 3 appearances she has statistically done better on average than EVERY OTHER CONTESTANT IN TOP CHEF HISTORY.
Other extraneous observation, Bryan Voltagiio is the only cheftastant who was never in danger of being eliminated. I could never really tell the Voltagiio's (they look kind of alike and neither of them really seem to have a personality) but I remember there season as being particularly boring. Collectively they wracked up more elimination wins than the other contestants combined and whenever they lost (with one exception) Kevin won. All three top contenders had ridiculous records that season. Which guess leads me to my initial questions about how fair the choices on Top Chef are.
When the same cheftestants mopped up all season it was less than exciting. So refusing to hand over a win based on a solid record is supposed to maintain some degree of suspense. I guess in theory that works. But in practice it just kind of sucks. At the end of season five I wasn't on the edge of my seat. I assumed Stefan would win as he completely dominated the competition. When he didn't I was in fact surprised... and a little insulted. Hosea was outmatched statistically not just by Stefan but by Carla as well. It didn't feel right to see someone who had been treading water all season be rewarded for it. Even more puzzling was Kevin's win in season 7. Five weeks he slipped through by the skin of teeth while Angelo and Ed were hitting home runs, but he's the one who got the title? I understand it, and honestly it wouldn't be fair not to consider a contestant. What would have been the point of sparing chefs elimination if they couldn't win? Everyone who made it through deserved a chance. But here's a thought... don't let them make it through if they regularly wound up in the bottom. If judges were forced to choose between someone like Tiffany (season 7) who had been in the top more than any other contestant and Kevin (season 7) who has been in the bottom with laughable frequency they should have given the pass to Tiffany. There needed to be some consideration of a chef's track record THROUGHOUT the show so people like Lisa didn't wind up making it to the end. It's just not fair for a woman who has won a single round and nearly gotten eliminated every other week to be considered alongside perpetual showstoppers Richard and Stephanie. For someone to spend almost half the competition serving up dishes that were poorly received and then be named the victor is stupid. Sure in season six Michael technically had a couple less compelling record than his competitors, but I certainly didn't mind when he came through at the end. That's because he wasn't doing the best, but he was doing very well all season. He had a record that was comparable to his competitors. I don't think there's something wrong with the underdog pulling it out, but the matchup needs to be reasonable. The judges really should be aware of the fact that certain people consistently fall in the bottom and chop them before they get to serve that final meal.
No comments:
Post a Comment